Now if I tell you that you suffer from delusions
Among my affectations is a mild disquiet over prayers for "vocations to the priesthood and religious life" during the General Intercessions. Yes, by all means let us pray for religious vocations. But why do we so rarely pray for marital vocations -- the vocation of eighty or ninety percent of Catholics? For that matter, how many religious vocations can we expect without healthy marital vocations?
Vocations to the priesthood are like the canary in the mine, they are
the first thing to die in an unhealthy environment. If in a few years a
diocese will have only a handful of priests then within a generation the
number of committed Catholics is going to match more or less the number
of those priests.
And, given the old grace perfecting nature angle, if we expect lots of the religious vocations we pray for to come from good Catholic families, then in a way praying for the end of religious vocations is praying for the means of marital vocations.
Though I still think we should pray for marital vocations, if only to make parents have to think about it when their kids ask what a marital vocation is.
Fr. Blake, incidentally, has a novel suggestion for local priest shortages:
My modest alternative proposal to lay-led services or importing priests
is simple, import foreign bishops! If a diocese doesn't have enough
priests or faces a steep decline, the problem must be with the "High
Priest","the Chief Catechist", the Bishop. It seems pretty pointless to
bring in Polish, Filipino or African priests only to have them drawn
into a clerical culture that does not produce fruit, what is needed is a
change of that culture, which only a bishop from outside can bring
about.
I don't know that only a bishop from outside can bring about that sort of change to the clerical culture, but it would certainly keep everyone on their toes.